Swiss Re Insurance-Linked Strategies Inc

Mt. Logan Capital Management, Ltd.

P&C soft market deepens, but profitability cushion will gradually erode: Swiss Re

Share

Swiss Re has forecast this morning that global non-life insurance premium growth is expected to accelerate over the next couple of years. But competition is driving prices down even as risks become more complex and this is likely to continue, until the profitability cushion gets eroded over time, the reinsurer explained.

swiss-re-instituteSwiss Re’s Institute published a new sigma report today on the global outlook for the economy and insurance over the next two years.

Global economic growth of 2.8% is forecast for 2027, an increase from an estimated 2.6% in 2026, followed by an expectation for 2.6% growth in 2028.

For the global non-life insurance and reinsurance market, Swiss Re’s Institute forecasts accelerating premium growth, from a 0.5% base in 2026.

For 2027, global non-life insurance premiums are forecast to grow by 1.0% in real terms, while for 2028 that is expected to double to 2.0% growth.

However, as the global non-life P&C insurance and reinsurance market continues to soften, Swiss Re expects that non-life premium growth will shift from being pricing-led, to being exposure-led going forwards.

“Growth will increasingly come from more assets and businesses needing insurance rather than higher prices,” the reinsurer explained today.

As a result, non-life insurer return-on-equity (ROE) is expected to dwindle due to reduced underwriting margins.

Swiss Re’s Institute saw non-life insurer ROE’s at 12.7% in 2026, but set to decline to 10.3% in 2027, after which the reinsurance firm believes ROE’s will continue to decline towards their cost-of-capital, at approximately 7.3% over the medium term.

Rising risks and new types or classes of risk are driving demand for protection, Swiss Re explains.

But, the market has been a victim of its own profitability success in recent years and it is the weight of capital, largely from profits, that is weighing on non-life re/insurance pricing now.

Jason Richards, CEO P&C Reinsurance UK & Ireland at Swiss Re, commented, “The insurance industry is well capitalised, putting it in a strong position to provide protection in an increasingly complex risk landscape. But having capital available is not the same as underwriting every risk. As risks become more interconnected, understanding how they accumulate is key to the industry deploying capacity where it can make the greatest difference and providing sustainable protection.”

The Swiss Re Institute sigma report states, “High non-life profitability driven among other factors, by strong investment income, is prolonging the soft market. But this support should fade as lower prices earn through portfolios and return on equity (RoE) converges towards the cost of capital.

“As excess returns narrow and risks become more interconnected, insurers may become more selective in deploying capacity, despite abundant capital. This distinction between capital and capacity matters more as natural catastrophe, liability and other risks become more complex and correlated, leading to greater differentiation in pricing and growth across risk pools.”

The non-life insurance and reinsurance industry currently has a capital cushion, created by its recent historical profitability, which is exacerbating the softening marketplace.

As returns converge towards the cost-of-capital, Swiss Re believes the softening may normalise at a certain level.

Swiss Re’s Institute believes the convergence of three factors could help to limit how low pricing can go in non-life insurance markets.

First, the fact premium growth is becoming exposure led, while in non-life AI-related capex and emerging markets are expanding the pool of insurable assets. Second, the market is expected to become increasingly fragmented and selective across performance of policies and portfolios, as well as risk understanding. And third, the increasing complexity and interconnectedness of risks.

“These pressures could limit how far pricing and terms can soften, even in a market with abundant capital,” the sigma report states.

As the softening continues Swiss Re expects, “Industry-wide underwriting margins to slide from 4.4% of premiums earned in 2026 to 1.7% in 2027, and to barely above 0% in 2028.”

Which would be, “Roughly in line with the 2016‒2022 average during the last global soft cycle.”

But the cushion of profitability is expected to erode over time, which may help to reduce some of the pressure, Swiss Re believes.

“This cushion may not last much longer as softer prices earn through portfolios, reserve support weakens and catastrophe losses revert towards trend. At the same time, claims severity pressures will persist given a volatile risk backdrop. Inflation in insurance-relevant categories, such as construction costs and medical treatment, is running above headline CPI inflation. The soft market may persist in the near term but underwriting conditions should gradually stabilise as industry RoE slides towards the cost of capital,” the reinsurer’s Institute explains in the sigma report.

Finally, Swiss Re also highlights that capital destruction is not always required for a soft market to come to an end. Rising uncertainty around the risks themselves can also be a trigger for a repricing.

At the same time, the increasing complexity of risks and their interconnected nature can also be a catalyst for more pressure on sector capacity, something illustrated by the global capital expenditure around artificial intelligence, technology and energy.

But ultimately, it is that capital cushion which has been created through hard market pricing years where profits have been sky-high that is the cause of the greatest pressure, as seen in reinsurance and even in areas such as catastrophe bonds where coupon earnings have been boosting the insurance-linked securities capital base.

The only question is how long it takes to erode the profitability cushion this time around? We have seen it take year’s in previous cycles.

It seems likely that some kind of exogenous shock(s) from outside the industry combined with elevated catastrophe loss experience, may now be required for any kind of meaningful repricing to occur.

Artemis Live - ILS and reinsurance video interviews and podcastView all of our Artemis Live video interviews and subscribe to our podcast.

All of our Artemis Live insurance-linked securities (ILS), catastrophe bonds and reinsurance video content and video interviews can be accessed online.

Our Artemis Live podcast can be subscribed to using the typical podcast services providers, including Apple, Google, Spotify and more.

Artemis Newsletters and Email Alerts

Receive a regular weekly email newsletter update containing all the top news stories, deals and event information

"*" indicates required fields

Receive alert notifications by email for every article from Artemis as it gets published.